implementation-review

Implementation Review Skill

Purpose

This skill ensures quality gates are enforced during the EPIC workflow by automatically invoking the appropriate review agents after task completion.

Review Triggers

1. Plan Review (Strategic-Planner Completion)

Trigger Conditions:

• strategic-planner agent has completed its planning tasks
• A strategy or implementation plan has been generated
• Keywords: "plan complete", "strategy ready", "planning done", "roadmap finalized"

Action: Delegate to plan-consultant agent for plan review

Review Focus:

• Plan completeness and feasibility
• Risk identification
• Alternative approaches consideration
• Alignment with project goals

2. Code Review (Main Agent Implementation Completion)

Trigger Conditions:

• Main agent has completed coding tasks in /implement workflow
• Implementation code has been written (after TDD Green phase)
• Keywords: "implementation complete", "coding done", "feature implemented", "code ready"

Action: Delegate to code-reviewer agent for code review

Review Focus:

• Code quality and maintainability
• Security vulnerabilities
• Performance considerations
• Adherence to project standards

Workflow Integration

EPIC Workflow with Reviews:

[Explore] -> [Plan] -> PLAN REVIEW -> [Implement] -> CODE REVIEW -> [Commit]
                           |                              |
                    plan-consultant               code-reviewer

Instructions

When Strategic-Planner Completes:

1. Detect completion signal from strategic-planner agent
2. Collect the generated plan/strategy document
3. Invoke plan-consultant agent with the plan for review
4. Report review findings back to main workflow
5. If critical issues found, flag for plan revision before proceeding

When Main Agent Completes Coding:

1. Detect completion of implementation tasks (TDD Green phase complete)
2. Identify all files modified during implementation
3. Invoke code-reviewer agent with the changed files
4. Report review findings back to main workflow
5. If critical issues found, flag for code revision before commit

Agent Delegation

| Completion Event | Review Agent | Purpose | |-----------------|--------------|---------| | strategic-planner done | plan-consultant | Validate implementation strategy | | Main agent coding done | code-reviewer | Validate code quality |

Review Report Format

After each review, expect a structured report:

## Review Summary
- **Reviewer:** [agent-name]
- **Rating:** [1-10]
- **Status:** [APPROVED / NEEDS REVISION / BLOCKED]

## Findings
- [Finding 1]
- [Finding 2]

## Recommendations
- [Recommendation 1]
- [Recommendation 2]

## Action Items
- [ ] [Required action if any]

Constraints

• DO NOT skip reviews - they are mandatory quality gates
• DO NOT proceed to next EPIC phase if review status is BLOCKED
• DO NOT modify code during review - only report findings
• Reviews should complete within reasonable time to not block workflow

Examples

Example 1: Plan Review Trigger

User: The strategic-planner has completed the implementation strategy for T001.