Phase 0: Programmatic SEO Feasibility Index (Required)
Before any strategy is designed, calculate the Programmatic SEO Feasibility Index.
Purpose
The Feasibility Index answers one question:
Is programmatic SEO likely to succeed for this use case without creating thin or risky content?
🔢 Programmatic SEO Feasibility Index
Total Score: 0–100
This is a diagnostic score, not a vanity metric. A high score indicates _structural suitability_, not guaranteed rankings.
Scoring Categories & Weights
| Category | Weight | | --------------------------- | ------- | | Search Pattern Validity | 20 | | Unique Value per Page | 25 | | Data Availability & Quality | 20 | | Search Intent Alignment | 15 | | Competitive Feasibility | 10 | | Operational Sustainability | 10 | | Total | 100 |
Category Definitions & Scoring
1. Search Pattern Validity (0–20)
- Clear repeatable keyword pattern
- Consistent intent across variations
- Sufficient aggregate demand
Red flags: isolated keywords, forced permutations
2. Unique Value per Page (0–25)
- Pages can contain meaningfully different information
- Differences go beyond swapped variables
- Conditional or data-driven sections exist
This is the single most important factor.
3. Data Availability & Quality (0–20)
- Data exists to populate pages
- Data is accurate, current, and maintainable
- Data defensibility (proprietary > public)
4. Search Intent Alignment (0–15)
- Pages fully satisfy intent (informational, local, comparison, etc.)
- No mismatch between query and page purpose
- Users would reasonably expect many similar pages to exist
5. Competitive Feasibility (0–10)
- Current ranking pages are beatable
- Not dominated by major brands with editorial depth
- Programmatic pages already rank in SERP (signal)
6. Operational Sustainability (0–10)
- Pages can be maintained and updated
- Data refresh is feasible
- Scale will not create long-term quality debt
Feasibility Bands (Required)
| Score | Verdict | Interpretation | | ------ | ------------------ | --------------------------------- | | 80–100 | Strong Fit | Programmatic SEO is well-suited | | 65–79 | Moderate Fit | Proceed with scope limits | | 50–64 | High Risk | Only attempt with strong controls | | <50 | Do Not Proceed | pSEO likely to fail or cause harm |
If the verdict is Do Not Proceed, stop and recommend alternatives.
Phase 1: Context & Opportunity Assessment
(Only proceed if Feasibility Index ≥ 65)
1. Business Context
- Product or service
- Target audience
- Role of these pages in the funnel
- Primary conversion goal
2. Search Opportunity
- Keyword pattern and variables
- Estimated page count
- Demand distribution
- Trends and seasonality
3. Competitive Landscape
- Who ranks now
- Nature of ranking pages (editorial vs programmatic)
- Content depth and differentiation
Core Principles (Non-Negotiable)
1. Page-Level Justification
Every page must be able to answer:
“Why does this page deserve to exist separately?”
If the answer is unclear, the page should not be indexed.
2. Data Defensibility Hierarchy
- Proprietary
- Product-derived
- User-generated
- Licensed (exclusive)
- Public (weakest)
Weaker data requires stronger editorial value.
3. URL & Architecture Discipline
- Prefer subfolders by default
- One clear page type per directory
- Predictable, human-readable URLs
- No parameter-based duplication
4. Intent Completeness
Each page must fully satisfy the intent behind its pattern:
- Informational
- Comparative
- Local
- Transactional
Partial answers at scale are high risk.
5. Quality at Scale
Scaling pages does not lower the bar for quality.
100 excellent pages > 10,000 weak ones.
6. Penalty & Suppression Avoidance
Avoid:
- Doorway pages
- Auto-generated filler
- Near-duplicate content
- Indexing pages with no standalone value
The 12 Programmatic SEO Playbooks
_(Strategic patterns, not guaranteed wins)_
- Templates
- Curation
- Conversions
- Comparisons
- Examples
- Locations
- Personas
- Integrations
- Glossary
- Translations
- Directories
- Profiles
Only use playbooks supported by data + intent + feasibility score.
Phase 2: Page System Design
1. Keyword Pattern Definition
- Pattern structure
- Variable set
- Estimated combinations
- Demand validation
2. Data Model
- Required fields
- Data sources
- Update frequency
- Missing-data handling
3. Template Specification
- Mandatory sections
- Conditional logic
- Unique content mechanisms
- Internal linking rules
- Index / noindex criteria
Phase 3: Indexation & Scale Control
Indexation Rules
- Not all generated pages should be indexed
- Index only pages with:
- Demand
- Unique value
- Complete intent match
Crawl Management
- Avoid crawl traps
- Segment sitemaps by page type
- Monitor indexation rate by pattern
Quality Gates (Mandatory)
Pre-Index Checklist
- Unique value demonstrated
- Intent fully satisfied
- No near-duplicates
- Performance acceptable
- Canonicals correct
Kill Switch Criteria
If triggered, halt indexing or roll back:
- High impressions, low engagement at scale
- Thin content warnings
- Index bloat with no traffic
- Manual or algorithmic suppression signals
Output Format (Required)
Programmatic SEO Strategy
Feasibility Index
- Overall Score: XX / 100
- Verdict: Strong Fit / Moderate Fit / High Risk / Do Not Proceed
- Category breakdown with brief rationale
Opportunity Summary
- Keyword pattern
- Estimated scale
- Competition overview
Page System Design
- URL pattern
- Data requirements
- Template outline
- Indexation rules
Risks & Mitigations
- Thin content risk
- Data quality risk
- Crawl/indexation risk
Related Skills
- seo-audit – Audit programmatic pages post-launch
- schema-markup – Add structured data to templates
- copywriting – Improve non-templated sections
- analytics-tracking – Measure performance and validate value
When to Use
This skill is applicable to execute the workflow or actions described in the overview.
Limitations
- Use this skill only when the task clearly matches the scope described above.
- Do not treat the output as a substitute for environment-specific validation, testing, or expert review.
- Stop and ask for clarification if required inputs, permissions, safety boundaries, or success criteria are missing.